2017 Hearn/Sky Sports v Warren/BT Sports Matchmaking Scoring Thread

R

Rob

Guest
#1


Now that we that Warren and Hearn are on clear level playing field I am giving this a reboot. For the time being we will primarily be scoring Sky & BT Shows that are shown in Primetime. There will be occasions where the shows are officially promoted, co-promoted with other promoters, these will count. There will be occasions where cards take place outside of the UK are predominantly filled with Hearn or Warren fighters, these will count. Shows on BoxNation only, Channel 5 or ITV will not be scored at this point. That may change depending on the activity of those channels/promoters.

I know there is not a universal agreement on the scoring system but it’s as close as we can get. There will be examples where a fight does not fit exactly within the criteria exactly but it will be given and agreed appropriate score.

The system that will be followed to score is the following;

Fights Scored

For Main events the score will be doubled. The same criteria can apply, but a fight can vary in its score by a point based on the criteria. The remaining fights will be complied based on;
a) Fights shown on TV
b) Title fights on the card
c) 12/10 scheduled round fights on the card
d) The best scoring scheduled 10 round+ fights on a card
e) Fights scheduled for the most rounds
f) Order fights were shown

Criteria

World Level - Between 2 fighters in the top 10 of their division
Domestic Level - Between 2 fighters proven at domestic level
Competitive - Not a mismatch.
Meaningful - Fight is happening for a reason (i.e title, eliminator, improve ranking)
*Fights less than 10 rounds can only score a maximum of 3/5

Before the fight

5 Points - World Level, Highly Competitive & Meaningful
4 Points - Domestic Level & Above, Competitive & Meaningful
3 Points - Competitive & Meaningful
2 Points - Not a Mismatch or Meaningful
1 Point - Mismatch

After the fight

5 Star - FOTY Candidate
4 Star - Competitive, Skilled & Entertaining
3 Star - Two of Competitive, Skilled or Entertaining
2 Star - One of Competitive, Skilled or Entertaining
1 Star - Mismatch

Final Scores

41+ GOAT
36-40 Excellent
31-35 Very Good
26-30 Good
21-25 Average
16-20 Poor
11-15 Very Poor
1-10 Awful



Hearn/Matchroom/Sky Sports (29/50 based on 12 Shows)

February 25th, Hull
McDonnell v Vargas 7/10 7/10
Campbell v Lopez 2/5 1/5
Coyle v Noble 3/5 2/5
Burnett v Reyes 1/5 2/5
25/50

March 25th, Manchester
Linares v Crolla II 8/10 6/10
Ward v Hughes II 3/5 3/5
Arnfield v Rose 3/5 3/5
Morrison v Welborn 2/5 3/5
31/50

April 15th, Glasgow
Burns v Indongo 9/10 6/10
Cardle v Barrett 3/5 4/5
Butcher v Edwards 3/5 2/5
Kelly v Byrne 3/5 3/5
33/50

April 22nd, Liverpool

Murray v Rosado 7/10 6/10
Fielding v Ryder 4/5 3/5
Dodd v Appleyard 3/5 4/5
Farrell v Carus 2/5 3/5
32/50

May 13th, Birmingham
Yafai v Muranak 6/10 7/10
Rodrigurez v Eggington 4/5 4/5
Yafai v Davis 3/5 3/5
Gavin v Garrido 2/5 2/5
31/50

June 10th, Belfast
Haskins v Burnett 8/10 5/10
Tennyson v Doyle 3/5 3/5
Hyland v Dingsdale 3/5 3/5
Tims v Watkins 3/5 2/5
30/50

June 30th, London

Buglioni v Summers 5/10 7/10
Cheesemen v Ryan 3/5 3/5
Belloti vSpreight 2/5 2/5
Benn v Cole 1/5 1/5
24/50

September 30, Liverpool

Butler v Hall II 7/10 6/10
Fielding v Brothy 3/5 3/5
Dodd v Stalker 3/5 4/5
Davies v Farrell 3/5 2/5
31/50

October 7th, Manchester

Burns v Crolla 7/10 5/10
Eggingtton v Minmoune 4/5 3/5
Ritson v Barrett 3/5 3/5
Benn v Clarke 1/5 1/5
27/50

October 21st, Belfast

Burnett v Zhakiyanov 9/10 7/10
Hyland v Ormond 3/5 4/5
Tennyson v Traynor 3/5 4/5
Kelly v Zuniga 2/5 1/5
33/50

November 4th, Monaco

Bivol v Broadbent 4/10 3/10
McDonnell v Solis 4/5 2/5
Chisora v Kaybel 4/5 2/5
Quigg v Yemimvoych 3/5 3/5
25/50

December 13th, London

Taylor v McCatskill 4/10 5/10
Ward v Gilner 4/5 3/5
Ball v Shinkwin 3/5 2/5
Kelly v Hamilcaro 2/5 2/5
26/50




Warren/Queensbury/BT Sports (31/50 based on 10 Shows)

April 8th, Manchester
Flangagan v Petrov 8/10 5/10
Williams v Smith 4/5 3/5
Catterall v Gethin 2/5 2/5
Kelly v Godding 3/5 4/5
30/50

April 22nd, Leicester
Langford v Khurtsidze 8/10 7/10
Nurse v Hughes 3/5 3/5
Tete v Villanueva 4/5 2/5
Smyle v Williams 3/5 5/5
35/50

May 13th, Leeds
Warrington v Martinez 6/10 8/10
Dickens v Ward 3/5 3/5
Leather v Suttcliffe 3/5 4/5
Adams v Salazar 2/5 2/5
31/50

May 20th, London
Davis v Walsh 8/10 6/10
Pickford v Morgan 3/5 4/5
Walsh v McCullough 3/5 3/5
Yarde Hobbs 2/5 2/5
31/50

July 8th, London

Skeete v Evans 7/10 3/5
Williams v Smyle 4/5 4/5
Cocoran v Ekundayo 3/5 2/5
Byfield v McNess 3/5 4/5
30/50

September 16th, London

Saunders v Monroe 7/10 5/10
Yarde v Nemesapati 2/5 2/5
Dubios v Carter 2/5 2/5
Sharp v Nagy 1/5 1/5
22/50

October 21st, Leeds

Warrington v Ceylon 8/10 7/10
Nurse v Catterall 4/5 3/5
Woodstock v Poxton 3/5 5/5
Barrett v Conwell 3/5 3/5
34/50

November 11th, Newcastle

Smith v Williams 8/10 7/10
Foot v Leather 4/5 5/5
Ward v Davis 3/5 3/5
Gorman v Soltby 3/5 3/5
36/50

November 18th, Belfast

Frampton v Garcia 5/10 8/10
Ancajas v Conlon 4/5 3/5
Barnes v Qezeda 2/5 3/5
Tete v Gonja 2/5 3/5
30/50

December 9th, London

DeGale v Truax 5/10 8/10
Selby v Ramierez 3/5 3/5
Yarde v Sjevola 4/5 4/5
Dubois-Darch 2/5 2/5
31/50
 
Last edited by a moderator:
R

Rob

Guest
#2
For those interested here is the previous thread and the historical scoring from the BoxNation era.

http://checkhookboxing.com/index.ph...matchmaking-vs-eddie-hearn-matchmaking.60472/

Warren/BoxNation
2011 Autumn/Winter 25/50
2012 Spring/Summer 21/50
2012 Autumn/Winter 26/50
2013 Spring/Summer 25/50
2013 Autumn/Winter 30/50
2014 Spring/Summer 26/50
2014 Autumn/Winter 24/50
2015 Spring/Summer 23/50
2015 Autumn/Winter 26/50
2016 Spring/Summer 25/50
2016 Autumn/Winter 22/50
Total Average - 25/50

Hearn/Sky

2012 Autumn/Winter 25/50
2013 Spring/Summer 30/50
2013 Autumn/Winter 28/50
2014 Spring/Summer 29/50
2014 Autumn/Winter 25/50
2015 Spring/Summer 26/50
2015 Autumn/Winter 26/50
2016 Spring/Summer 29/50
2016 Autumn/Winter 30/50
Total Average - 29/50

 

Roe

Ethical Cunt
Staff member
Jun 1, 2012
17,450
3,498
350
@roe617
#3
Too many 20 something seasons, not enough 30+s.

The thing about Arsenal is they always..
 
Jun 5, 2012
8,234
3,180
150
33
England
#5
I will be shouted down and I do still think it could be a circus act but Haye hasn`t fought anyone for 5 years I would bump it up to 4.
Disagree, its a mismatch and should be a 1, mismatches should be punished severely.

Same with Campbells fight, that is a mismatch and should be punished with a 1.
 

One to watch

CHB WORLD CHAMPION 2018
Jun 5, 2013
57,847
29,432
450
#13
I was excited about the BT deal but I worry that it's going to divide this forum and other british based sites into even more conflicted hearn v warren,Sky v BN based chat.

That's fine in here of course,but I can see it infiltrating every bloody thread before long and I just want to see them both put together decent,regular shows without getting bogged down in the promotional war.